Retentions must be held in trust, say ECA and BESA
Trade bodies respond to announcement of government retentions consultation
25 October 2017
Any cash held as retentions by construction clients and major contractors ‘must be held in trust at the nearest opportunity’, the BESA and ECA have advised the government. This proposed ‘Australian-style’ system would mean cash being held cyclically, in a similar manner to deposits in the private housing rental market.
Looking ahead, the two engineering services trade bodies want to see cash retentions completely phased out, in order to protect suppliers from poor retention practices. At present, large businesses retain the cash in their own bank accounts, for use in a manner of their choosing.
The comments follow the release today (24 October) of an independent review of the current state-of-play on retentions by consultancy Pye Tait, and the announcement of a government consultation on the issue. In the government response, they recognise that ‘some payment practices prevalent in construction are a barrier to investment, productivity improvements and growth’.
ECA Director of Business Paul Reeve and BESA Director of Commercial and Legal Rob Driscoll jointly commented:
“While the significant and unacceptable problems of cash retentions in construction have been identified by independent research, and even acknowledged by government, the government has chosen to consult once again on the extent of the problem and what to do about it.
“The BESA and the ECA will continue to call on the government to ensure that all cash retentions are held in trust as soon as possible, and to phase them out entirely by the early 2020s. For the good of the economy, and the supply chain, we need a firm commitment to remove the retentions issue.”
Some £10.5 billion of the overall construction sector turnover of £220 billion is held in retentions. An estimated £7.8 billion has been unpaid across the construction sector over the last three years. Some £40 million of retentions is lost by small firms each year due to upstream insolvencies. Banks do not consider unprotected retentions as security for lending purposes to SMEs.
The ECA and the BESA will both be responding to the government consultation on retentions, which will run until 19 January 2018.